To ‘Opt-Out’ or NOT to ‘Opt-Out’

The Smart Meter ‘Opt-Out’ Programs of
DTE Energy and Consumers Energy
By David Sheldon

(Revised 5/9/15)

Many of you will be receiving an ‘Opt-Out’ Notice letter from DTE Energy or Consumers Energy soon.  The letter says if you don’t want a radio transmitting smart meter on your home you must sign up for their ‘opt out’ plan, thereby agreeing to let them put a “smart meter” aka “AMI meter” on your home with the “radio turned off”, and that you agree to pay both an initial fee and monthly fees indefinitely for this.  The letter indicates that if you do not sign up for their plan they will put a fully functioning smart meter on your home.  We think these ‘opt-out’ plans are a farce and a sham and, for most people, will not solve the problems for which an opt-out was requested in the first place.

But we think there is a third alternative not mentioned in their letter.  If you still have your analog meter we think your best course of action is NOT to sign up for one of these plans.  Instead, send DTE or Consumers a letter indicating that you are not signing up for their plan, but that you also refuse your consent for them to install a smart meter.  To make this work you need to lock your analog meter and post a sign next to it saying that you do not consent to installation of any smart meter or “digital meter”.

In view of two recent decisions by the Michigan Court of Appeals (MCOA), some clarification is needed as to your legal right to defend your life and your home against these meters. See the newly added section “LEGAL BASIS FOR REFUSING AN ADVANCED METER” at the end of this article.

Detailed instructions on how to lock down your meter can be found elsewhere on this website.  A copy of the DTE Notice letter and a form letter you can use to answer it can be found on this website.

It is possible that DTE or Consumers will begin billing you for the initial and monthly opt-out fees based on your refusals.  If so we would recommend you pay those fees but pay them under protest.  To not pay them would cause you to fall into arrears on your monthly utility bill and provide a pretext for the utility to terminate your service.  Write a letter to the utility stating that you will pay the fees under protest, and write the words “opt-out fees paid under protest” on your bill stub and on your check.  There will come a time when you may be able to join in a class action lawsuit to recover those fees.

If you already have a smart meter you may well have been waiting to see if there would be a real opt-out plan before making your move.  Your best course of action will depend on how committed you wish to be in defending your life and your health.  The preferred course of action is to send DTE or Consumers a letter demanding removal of the smart meter within 14 days and restoral of an electro-mechanical analog meter such as you had before the smart meter.  Your letter should state that if the company will not remove the smart meter you will do it yourself, replacing it with an analog meter you can buy on the internet.

If you do proceed to purchase and install an analog meter we strongly recommend you have an electrically knowledgeable person do it.  It is a 5 minute job but it could possibly be botched by someone unfamiliar with electrical things. It would also be a good idea to watch the Jerry Day video for pointers about this on

Two years ago, when the first two families changed their own meters, they were taken to court by DTE seeking an injunction to force the families to allow re-installation of a smart meter. In one of these cases the judge denied DTE’s motion for such an injunction and agreed to further consider the dispute after the appeals of MPSC rulings are decided. In the other case the judge granted the motion for an injunction but the injunction has proved to be unenforceable while the couple is appealing this case to the Michigan Court of Appeals. Both of these these families still have the analog meter they installed themselves and both still have their power on. Since then many families have changed their own meter without being taken to court and without loss of their electric service. Bottom line is that while there are some risks to changing your own meter those risks appear to be much less than we once thought.

A less desirable alternative, or ‘plan B’, would be to sign up for DTE’s opt-out plan.  This will not protect your privacy nor will it eliminate all of the radiation, but at least this will eliminate some of the radiation.  You can then consult with an emf abatement specialist to see whether special filters or other measures could be taken to minimize any remaining radiation.

When considering which plan best fits your needs, you will want to decide how important your health and your Fourth Amendment rights actually are.


In view of two recent decisions by the Michigan Court of Appeals (MCOA), some clarification is needed as to your legal right to defend your life and your home against these meters.The appeals were of decisions made by the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) wherein that agency maintained that it had no jurisdiction to tell a privately owned monopoly utility what kind of meters to use on private homes and businesses. Note that the MPSC did not make smart meters legal or make resistance to them unlawful. When the appeals court reviews an MPSC decision it limits its review to whether that agency made a mistake or not. It does not usually reach more fundamental issues as to the rights of the public. In these cases the MCOA held that MPSC was correct in concluding it had no jurisdiction over this meter issue. What the appeals court did not determine was whether the smart meters are legal or not or whether claims based on constitutional or property rights issues could be brought by individual utility customers. A detailed discussion of these appeal decisions can be found under our “Legal” tab.

We hold that the forced smart meter programs of DTE and of Consumers are illegal on their face. But that is a case that is yet to be won. It must be brought in one or more of the state’s circuit courts and ultimately reach the Michigan Court of Appeals again. But in this context the MCOA will have much broader jurisdiction to consider the legality and constitutionality of the whole program and not limit its inquiry to whether or not MPSC made a mistake in its ruling.

The case that needs to be brought in circuit court(s) is that the smart meter ‘opt-out’ programs of both DTE and Consumers are illegal because they seek to force smart meters on non-consenting customers and:

(1) The devices these utilities are installing do not meet the legal definition of ‘meter’ as that term has been defined by the Michigan legislature.  This is no trivial matter. Homeowners and business owners have a right to control access to their property and what can be done on or to their property. These rights are protected by the law of trespass. The legislature created a conditional  modification of these property rights when it made installation of a “meter” on the property a condition for receiving electrical service from a monopoly public utility. The legislature created this modification of property rights based on its understanding of what a “meter” is, which understanding has been codified in law and regulations ever since. The utilities now claim a right to install a radio-transmitting computer on each and every home and business. Worse, they believe they have the right to force installation of a radio-transmitting computer on every customer as a condition for receiving what has become a necessity of modern living.

(2) The legislature never authorized surveillance devices to be installed on Michigan homes or businesses.  In fact what the legislature did do was pass a statute making it a felony to install a surveillance device on a home without the homeowner’s knowledge and consent.

(3) The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution gives every homeowner the right to be secure in his home and to have an expectation of privacy there. The Fourth Amendment is routinely applied when law enforcement seeks access to the home. A warrant, issued by a court and supported by an oath based on probable cause is required. But the courts have also held that the Fourth Amendment and its warrant requirement apply to non-governmental persons or entities when they are acting as “state agents”, i.e. when they are carrying out certain actions at the behest of government and not at their own initiative or entirely for their own purposes. Smart grid and smart meters were not initiated by privately owned utilities. They were instigated by governments – at the national and international levels.

(4) It is provable that certain people are “electro-hypersensitive” and that the kind of radio energy put out by smart meters will cause them immediate symptoms. This is a type of disability that these folks have that makes them not able to tolerate what the majority of the population may be able to tolerate. The Americans with Disability Act requires businesses to make reasonable accommodations so persons with disabilities can participate in society. The utilities are not making the kind of accommodations the law requires. As a result people with this disability are being forced into chronic illness or find that they have to live without something most people consider a necessity.

(5) There is a case to be made, though a much more difficult one in terms of evidentiary burden, that the entire population may have its long run health imperiled by these meters. Accordingly, each utility customer should have the right to choose whether or not to assume such a risk. An ‘opt-out’ program that still requires every customer to have a smart meter that can cause these long run consequences is not a true opt-out. Moreover the charging of a fee for those unwilling to risk their long run health is obscene.

19 thoughts on “To ‘Opt-Out’ or NOT to ‘Opt-Out’

  1. Hello, I had no idea about the dangers and issues with smart meters but have now been informed. I have Consumers Energy and DTE and have smart meters installed on both meters. The Consumers one was done recently a couple months ago. What are my options to have these removed? Preferably the route I want to go is removing these meters and going back to the regular mechanical style due to concerns over fire, radiation, privacy, etc. Please guide me, thank you in advance.

    • … Baaahahaha.. Good Luck Jeff.. It looks like the only thing that can be done, is remove them at a state level. and until our gov. starts getting a good spanking, there will be no change, our gov has been bought off and can care less,, until they themselves drop dead over the new smart meters,.. Why they sell their souls to the devil, amazes me.. but they have.
      Ben ….

  2. Could you please give me information on how I can handle my electric company if I moved into my apartment and they already have the smart meters in? I had no idea when I moved in a year ago about the dangers of smart meters.

    Thank you

    Virginia Sargent

    • Virginia, Answer may depend on which utility company you have. If you have Consumers you may be able to get them to install, in return for initial and monthly opt-out fees, a digital electric meter that is not a smart meter and contains no radio transmitters. If you have DTE there is no escape from the smart meter short of terminating your service and living off grid. For an initial plus monthly fees DTE will turn off the radios in your smart meter (maybe). You will still suffer health effects and a loss of privacy and risk of fire from lightning and line voltage surges.

  3. Does anyone know how to get the city water department to remove or allow removal of a Neptune E-coder 900i water meter? Mine was installed (in my house, next to the water heater) 3 years ago. After developing symptoms (worsening autoimmune disease plus a Parkinsons-like tremor) shortly afterward (I attributed these at the time to increased WiFi at a temporary job), I called the city in summer 2015 and asked how “smart” the meter was. What they told me, it sounded like it was only “smart” when they read it from the street 4 times a year. Well, 2 weeks ago a guy from the water department came around and said they wanted to install an even smarter meter which would just emit continuously without even needing to be radio-read. I then did a little research on the Neptune meter and found that it emits every 14 seconds, and not mild radiation either. I have been chronically unwell for almost 3 years and would DEARLY love to get this thing out of my house. (I still have my electrical analog meter – I opted out and so far Consumers has respected my wishes, although they smart-metered the rest of my neighborhood last summer.) I have never faced this kind of situation before and have no idea how to approach the water department. Do I offer to pay extra? More importantly, if they absolutely say no, can I have a non-radiating meter installed myself (the way people have been doing with the electrical meters from the Jerry Day website)? Does anyone have any expertise they can offer me? I have not yet talked to the water department about this. I would appreciate any advice anyone has to offer.

    • Debi, Your options may depend on what city you are in. Some cities have made accomodations, others simply turn your water off if you refuse their smart meter. There is a bill in the Michigan legislature to give everyone the right to opt-out of smart water meters. It is House bill 4338 before the Local Government Committee. Suggest you write a letter to each of the members of that committee urging its passage.

  4. I live in grand rapids mi I would like to have my smart meter removed. I purchased a radiation decetor and the smart meter is giving off a deadly amount of radiation.

    • I know your feeling my power was shut off at the pole for refusing the smart meter. Call representatives and they said by law there is nothing they could do! I am taking care of a 96 year old that is blind, a 94 year old that has dementia, and needs to have power equipment to do anything, even bathroom. It seems DTE can do whatever they want and you have no say so. either way we have to get two smart meters put in because the ladies have to have air conditioning to survive! This is not right but not enough people care. So we are tying to get to freedom, but the corporations are getting a free ride to impose whatever they want. Sad state and the ones to blame are the people that don’t care enough to stand up and our elected representatives. What ever happen to freedom. The MPSC is only interested in the corporations pocket book. This is sad, soon we will be called part of the American Union and the only one to blame is the people that say how could we let this happen!

    • Can you please tell me exactly which detector you used? I would like to test my meter, too. Have you been successful in getting the meter removed? Are you dealing with DTE or Consumers Energy?

  5. I read in a new book called The New New Deal (can’t remember author but it’s on amazon and the author liked Obama), that Obama was the beginning for these things. he wanted to start en electric grid and his staff said, Well. we don’t have anything to do it with.” and he said, “Well, find something to start it with.” You can find his words on amazon in the book.
    It is all about starting this globalism..

    • You are so right! But today not even the republicans care enough about their own people and let the corporations do their job at the expense of the people! Vote them all out. I try every election! Two terms they are out without lifetime pay and benefits! They go back and live like us, that is the way it’s supposed to be!.

  6. Im in this boat. I dont know how severe my sensitivity is but ever since one was installed and 5 next door, with another 7 at other neighbors, my health has gone to shit. Nothing super serious like tumors or cancer yet, but still serious. Diagnosed last year after a 3 year investigation of why my health went sour so quick. Chronic fatigue, dizziness, ear ringing, cant sleep well, headaches, serious confusion at times, serious memory issues, numbess in hands and arms, sometimes numb legs. Had my arm go numb for 30 hours, went to ER, some test, couldnt find anything, come back if doesnt change…I get no where with doctors. Finally found this via you tube and install dates line up with health decline. Im in Grand Rapids MI What can I do to get analog back? I will inform neighbors once i have some info. They have a new born who sleeps 10 to 15 ft from all 5 of them on their home!


  7. Yes, we are in the “good ol USA, where freedom reigns”…right? Seems to me more and more things are being MANDATED here and our supposed “freedom” is readily disappearing right before our eyes. We ARE being told what to do – with no choices. And, history repeats itself.

    • So true, But it is the ones that know and do nothing that are stopping us from taking back our freedom and back to the Constitution! I know why to, because the welfare state would stop and people would have to earn their keep. That is the beauty of the Constitution, it’s based on how hard you want to work. The people stop themselves from becoming wealthy. And now the government is trying to keep them in the class they are and worse. Today it is all about money, no compassion for their fellow man, no mom and pop, and to make it as hard as they can for we the people to survive. Our elected representatives, all they care about is which one is looking better then the other and, fighting between each other! Where do the people come in, Nowhere!

  8. I do not want to fill forced to take something that will 1. Cause my health to become worse. 2. Nor for anyone to know any of my private business. 3. This is the USA we should have the right to say NO AND NO BE THE ANSWER. TO WHAT WE DO NOT WANT ON OUR HOME OR IN OUR LIVES.

  9. My Son and I live across the road from one another and we opted out of consumers smart meter. I didn’t know that we could just refuse the meter. We both received a bill for 69.00 with in days of opt out. We wrote on the bill that we were paying the bill in protest and wrote it right on the bill. I guess that next month we will be billed the 9.72 for the meter to be read. Didn’t know what else to do so thanks for all your good work. Randy

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s