Senator Colbeck Calls for Shutoff Moratorium

December 21st, 2017 – Senator Colbeck Calls for Electric Shut-Off Moratorium. Welcomes formal MPSC investigation.

LANSING, Mich. — State Sen. Patrick Colbeck, R-Canton, said on Thursday that he welcomed the announcement of a formal investigation into the electric shut-off practices of DTE and called for a moratorium on such practices until the investigation was completed.

“In October our office began to see a big increase in the number of constituents contacting us and complaining about inappropriate shut-off notices and other problems that we reported to the MPSC,” Sen. Colbeck said. “As the months got colder those problems shockingly got worse instead of better. This formal investigation by the MPSC is going to clearly show that people were being threatened with shut-off notices they never should have received, resulting in turn with many of them then having their power inappropriately disconnected. In addition, getting power turned back on also took much longer than it is legally supposed to.

“This has gone beyond just minor billing snafus and has unacceptably created significant stress, hardship, and endangerment for hundreds of people whose simple wish is to pay their bills and receive electric service. Especially in Michigan where people can’t just change their utility provider when they’re treated like this, it is imperative that we hold both our utilities and our oversight 110 percent accountable.”

Now that the extent of the problem is being acknowledged, Sen. Colbeck also called for the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) to put a moratorium on DTE’s ability to shut off power to their residential customers until the investigation over the shut-off and billing problems has been completed. Power was wrongly cut for many reasons, but as an example, the investigation notice highlighted that at least 288 customers had their service improperly disconnected because of simple computer-related billing errors over the past six months.

“This investigation is still necessary, but it is already a forgone conclusion that DTE’s computer problems are causing people to have power cut because of internal communication problems within DTE that incorrectly put people at risk for being flagged for shut-off,” said Colbeck. “I’ve had people contact me one week saying they got an inappropriate shut-off notice, were assured the next week that it wouldn’t happen, and then a few days later they would call my office back because DTE had returned to their home threatening shut-off again.

“Until the investigation shows the exact steps that need to be taken to fix all of this, it would be prudent for the MPSC to, at the very least, have to pre-approve all residential shut-offs while this investigation is ongoing. A moratorium would be an even better course of action if simple billing errors that could affect anyone would result in shut-offs that jeopardize ratepayer health and personal safety during our cold winter months.”

Sen. Colbeck said while the main concern is for seniors, especially those who live by themselves, that in today’s high tech world a lack of power impacts everyone.

“Older individuals would be calling from the library asking for help because their VOIP phones would not work with the power off and they had no way to recharge their cell phones,” Sen. Colbeck said. “When they would try to contact DTE they could often only leave a message, but had no working phone for DTE to even call them back on. Those who could not rely on the help of neighbors were significantly impacted.

“But even younger families faced hardships beyond the cold. People’s computers would not work, and their kids were missing school assignments. Burglar alarms were down. Birthday parties and Thanksgiving plans were disrupted. Even for people who received notices but didn’t get shut off, they went through several stressful weeks waiting for the other shoe to drop and were oftentimes afraid to leave their homes unattended for fear of finding their power cut when they returned.”

Sen. Colbeck also highlighted that because the MPSC only knows what it is told that it is critical that people call the MPSC to lodge complaints. If people don’t call, the extent of the investigation will be understated. People should call 1.800.292.9555 for any complaint they have, even if the incident occurred several months ago.

Sen. Colbeck’s previous press release on the matter also drew attention to the fact that the MPSC currently does not formally ask the utilities to report why people have their electric power involuntarily shut off. Sen. Colbeck said he felt that would be an issue that would hamper the investigation and shows the need for changes in reporting.

“State administrative rules need to be rewritten so that something like this can’t happen again,” Sen. Colbeck said. “I believe that the current law requires more detailed reporting than what the utilities are now submitting to the MPSC, but in any event it is clear that the MPSC has the legal ability to now retroactively ask for those details as they conduct this investigation. For example, it has been extremely frustrating for me to see people getting their power turned off because they simply want to keep their analog meter, to then be told that it is a rare occurrence, but then be unable to get the actual data on how frequently it is happening.

“For a start we need to change the rules that allow for such meter-choice related shut-offs, that encourage lax reporting, and that allow utilities to take too long restoring power without experiencing any real ramifications.  Waiting a week to get power restored in the cold is simply too long, especially when the person shouldn’t even be getting their power cut in the first place.”

Sen. Colbeck said that the type of behavior being exemplified by the shut-offs shows why both utility choice and meter-choice urgently need to be reexamined.

“Until people can vote with their feet we’ll continue to see these problems,” Sen. Colbeck said. “People deserve the right to flee poor service when it jeopardizes their health and well-being.”

Please also check out our Home page and
consider making a donation to support our
ongoing efforts to educate through this
site and through flyering in the districts of
House Energy Committee members who have
been holding up passage of House Bill 4220.





8 thoughts on “Senator Colbeck Calls for Shutoff Moratorium

  1. DTE is still cutting people off!!!!!!!! They got us in senior season on Nov 2nd and they got others well into December!!!!

    • Tracy, we have not heard of anyone being shut off after mid-November, except for supposed non-payment of bills. Please put those people in touch with us at People keep telling me that DTE is continuing to shut people off, but no one has offered any proof. Usually, I get called by 1/2 to 2/3 of people who get shut off.

  2. I tried the 800 number, but they had no clue what to do with anything I had to say in regards to being threatened with shutoff for noncompliance. . .

  3. Is there any news pertaining to Consumers Energy? Homeowners feel powerless against them. You can tell them you won’t accept a smart meter or digital meter all you want, but they just wait until you aren’t home and install it (that’s what they did to us).

    • karen and john, the ONLY way to prevent installation of a smart or digital meter is to lock your meter housing or have a fence and locked gate so that they can only access the meter by appointment. If you do these things you should write a letter making clear that you are not denying them access to their meter, but only qualifying that access to be by appointment and for any purpose other than installation of a digital meter. They may access their meter to read it, repair it, test it or replace it with another analog meter if they believe it to be defective. They may not access it to install a surveillance device that is nowhere authorized by law, or to install an ‘opt-out meter’ that is known to make vulnerable people ill. But now that you already have a digital meter there is probably no solution other than to move, unless or until we can get meter choice legislation passed. Please phone your representatives in the Michigan state legislature and tell them you want analog choice legislation passed (House Bill 4220).

  4. Please be aware that DTE has stopped the shut-offs. The last shut-off occured in early November. DTE shut off only a small number of people (about 30), though we estimate it sent out shut-off notices to several hundred in October 2017. DTE has also agreed that it will not shut off any seniors over the winter months. Because of the widespread publicity about the shut-offs that did occur, and Sen Colbeck’s valiant efforts, DTE has ceased to issue shut-off notices and has instead taken to stepped-up intimidation tactics, including robo-calls and repeated visits by bullying personnel to people’s homes. All of those who refuse to cave in to these threats have kept their analog meters.

    To reiterate: DTE attempted to intimidate everyone into caving in by shutting off electricity to about 30 people in October and early November (as well as others scattered throughout the last couple of years). Its October efforts didn’t work, DTE got in the news multiple times, and DTE is has reverted to in-person intimidation and threats and to phone calls. We’ve received many calls from people, and those who stand firm keep their meter.

    Please also be aware that the number of shut-offs by DTE has been small relative to the number of meters that are still analog. DTE has said it has another 20,000 smart meters to install. That’s a lot of people resisting!

    To learn more about DTE’s current tactics, please see this PDF:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s